This is what has been working well for me (Black Dragon horoscope)
1. Melted Titanium Shard
2. Melted Vanadium Shard
3. Titanium Ingot
4. Vanadium Ingot
If I need to fail I use
1. Iron Ingot
2. Melted Zinc Shard
3. Melted Tin Shard
4. Zinc Ingot
2
Anonymous 17-08-2016 07:40
Horoscope doesn't work like that. If your horoscope matches theirs you get a bonus of 10% of the amity you earned that game, otherwise it has no effect. Make an alt with camel horoscope and buy/make it a matching calpheon noble's costume for total 25% boosted amity with this npc.