Press F1 is faster

The range on this guy's Interest level and Favor is just plain stupid... you'll burn a lot of Amity getting absolutely anywhere. Buckle up.

I suggest re-rolling the conversation until his Interest Level is at least under 40, and his Favor under or close to 20. I personally would cut the conversation short if I could nab 50 or more Amity since it's really easy to get a requirement and fail.

Best Overall Combo I came up with: (I favored success over completely optimizing amity gain)
1. Birth of Faith
2. After Death
3. Evil Gods of Darkness
4. Dragon Watcher
5. Bell Ringing from the City
6. Road to Penitence

Here are 2 different conversation flows i used.
Birth of Faith ;;;Will of Elion
Will of Elion ;;;After Death
Evil Gods in Darkness ;;;Evil Gods of Darkness
Elion Definition of Hersey ;;;Elion Definition of Hersey
After Death ;;;Birth of Faith
Dragon Watcher ;;;Dragon Watcher

Here are 2 images of each conversation when it goes right (note i am wearing +15% amnity clothes). Amnity Gained.

This guy's amity game is horrible (nearly impossible to win, and if you do you'll get 20 amity max). If you're going for the knowledge, just dump a bunch of energy greeting him for 300 amity. The knowledge at 700 amity can be obtained elsewhere much easier.

My Horoscope is Black Dragon (Not sure if it matters) but I found none of the others good at all, so I'll post a good combo I found myself in case others have same problems.

1. Dragon watcher
2. Birth of faith
3. After Death
4. Road of penitence
5. Bell Ringing from the city
6. Evil Gods in Darkness

Having a character with Goblin Astralogic sign is highly recommanded for this npc

Here are 2 conversation flows I got to work for me.
Birth of Faith;;;Will of Elion
Will of Elion;;;After Death
Evil Gods of Darkness;;;Evil Gods of Darkness
Elion Definition of Hersey;;;Elion Defintion of Hersey
After Death;;;Birth of Faith
Dragon Watcher;;;Dragon Watcher

Here are the results of each after 3 successful conversation (I am wearing a +15% amnity shirt)Amnity Gained

Guys, only press F5 in front of him and it will be easier...Just a joke, a loose of time and a loose of energy, even with decent Interest and Favor i did 78 amity... F5 is better, safer and can be spam with a amity potion too (+3 per F5)

Updated 2019
Wolfgang Knowledge
1. Birth of Faith
2. Will of Elion
3. An Elionian Definition of Heresy
4. Evil Gods in Darkness
5. Road of Repentance
6. Bell Ringing from the City

I recommend getting the amity for the NPC via the f5 greet and the f5 greet only. Getting it via the minigame just isn't worth it. You're highly likely to get win condition that will be impossible to complete and you'll just waste 2 energy.
Using 3 energy to wave sucks but with a few select NPCs it actually ends up being the less energy-wasting option.

Calpheon Ovası - Kuzey Calpheon

https://youtu.be/F3rjZr5gKQE

This what work for me. I can get 120+ amity.

1. Will of Elion
2. After Death
3. Dragon Watcher
4. Road of Repentance
5. Birth of Faith
6. Bell Ringing from the City

Only took me 50ish energy.

Actual

Will of Elion
Dragon Watcher
Birth of Faith
Road of Penitence
After Death
Bell Ringing from the City

WTF is this Screenshot
Pls the names inside or its useless